Historum - History Forums  

Go Back   Historum - History Forums > World History Forum > Ancient History
Register Forums Blogs Social Groups Mark Forums Read

Ancient History Ancient History Forum - Greece, Rome, Carthage, Egypt, Mesopotamia, and all other civilizations of antiquity, to include Prehistory and Archaeology discussions


View Poll Results: The Odyssey vs. The Illiad vs The Aeneid
The Odyssey 19 42.22%
The Illiad 18 40.00%
The Aeneid 8 17.78%
Voters: 45. You may not vote on this poll

Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old August 16th, 2012, 04:51 PM   #1

SW412's Avatar
Archivist
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 171
Blog Entries: 2
The Odyssey vs. The Illiad vs. The Aeneid


Which of these is your favorite, and why?

Personally, I prefer The Aeneid to The Odyssey, but I hear the The Illiad (which I haven't yet read, but plan to) is superior to *both* of them.

Opinions?
SW412 is offline  
Remove Ads
Old August 16th, 2012, 04:57 PM   #2

Clodius's Avatar
Theomachos
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,699
Blog Entries: 19

(Having just complained about vs. threads on another discussion, I'm going to be a hypocrite and actually participate in this one, because I like the look of it!)

I voted for the "Odyssey" - it's simply the most fun, and the question was which is my "favourite". However, I think the Iliad is superior as a work of art, and as a complete, satisfying, well-characterised, beautifully-constructed narrative. I also think that the "Aeneid" is the most interesting, because it is the most "literary" (the Iliad and the Odyssey were products of an oral rather than a written tradition), and the political dimensions of the poem, with the shadow of Augustus always lurking in the background, can be endlessly discussed and dissected.

However, the question wasn't which is the greatest work of art, or which is the most interesting, it was which is your favourite - and on that basis I voted for the Odyssey. That's the one I'd take to a desert island, because it's just a blast!
Clodius is offline  
Old August 16th, 2012, 05:01 PM   #3
Suspended indefinitely
 
Joined: Jun 2012
From: Constantinople
Posts: 2,248

I like The Odyssey more because I really like the story and the character and I've read it countless of times when I was trying to write something as a gift to someone and I was really trying to "sound" like Homer therefore even memorised some parts of the Odyssey so I like it better.
Farinal is offline  
Old August 16th, 2012, 05:10 PM   #4

Propagandist's Avatar
Archivist
 
Joined: May 2012
From: Cardiff,Wales
Posts: 202

Quote:
Originally Posted by Clodius View Post
(Having just complained about vs. threads on another discussion, I'm going to be a hypocrite and actually participate in this one, because I like the look of it!)
I was thinking the exact same thing! Well I guess I have brought shame to my entire family by being a hypocrite.

Anyway I prefer the Iliad particularly because I find it most informative for the purposes of military history and representative of the ideological concerns of the era. Although, the Telemachy interests me incredibly, as far as enjoyment of the stories go I find that the Illiad just happens to contain some of my favorite mythological figures in Achilles, Hector, Diomedes, and Telamonian Ajax.

The Aeneid doesn't really interest me as much. That may be a result of forcing myself to read it in an entire day. (While my roommate forced himself to read Paradise Lost in the same time frame It was a pretty miserable 100F degree day with no air conditioning...)
Propagandist is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 08:52 AM   #5

Midas's Avatar
Γορδιεϝαις the Phrygian
 
Joined: Dec 2011
From: Scandinavia, Balkans, Anatolia & Hatay
Posts: 3,352
Blog Entries: 4

I went for the Iliad because it has so many different ethnic groups and heroes involved!
Midas is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 09:12 AM   #6

MinoanGoddess's Avatar
Historian
 
Joined: May 2012
From: New York City
Posts: 1,638
Blog Entries: 4

The Odyssey makes a better and smoother read in Ancient Greek, especially when you also have to do a literal translation
MinoanGoddess is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 09:23 AM   #7

SW412's Avatar
Archivist
 
Joined: May 2012
Posts: 171
Blog Entries: 2

I voted for The Aeneid, myself - I recently finished it, and loved it. However, I may be biased because it includes a great deal of Italian mythological-history. Although, at times, it did feel a bit like a propaganda piece - but I suppose politics and Ancient Rome go hand-in-hand.

I think I'm definitely going to have to give The Odyssey another try; when I first read it, I found it dry, but I was so young, then. I believe I'd enjoy it much more, now (especially since I didn't find The Aeneid dull, in the least).
SW412 is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 10:04 AM   #8

M.E.T.H.O.D.'s Avatar
Burgundian Janitor
 
Joined: Aug 2011
From: Galway/Gaillimh
Posts: 3,435
Blog Entries: 4

Regarding the plot, I feel like the Aeneid is superior(plus it has the badass Mezentius);however the Iliad contains superior epic moments and it is, in my opinion, much more emotional(examples: death of Patroclus,Andromache and Hector's last encounter,Priam pleading for his son's corpse)
M.E.T.H.O.D. is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 12:39 PM   #9

Gile na Gile's Avatar
Tame O' Tama Shanterin
 
Joined: May 2008
From: Fireland
Posts: 3,509
Blog Entries: 122

Odyssey for me, Illiad just never quite manages to reach the same heights, though they are both superb.

The Aeneid is a different ball-game altogether and shouldn't even be mentioned in the same breath as the latter, belonging as it does to a totally different category of artistic production - more like Goebbels on steroids really. Whereas the great Greek oral epics are crafted organically over many genrerations with each successive bard adding his/her own personal embellishments until we finally reached that apogee of perfection wherein Homer took all the tangled roots together and welded the tales we now enjoy, the Aeneid was self-consciously manufactured as a propagandistic tool to legitimise the Augustan transition towards dictatorship.

Poor old Virgil was whipped from his bucolic slumber and commissioned to eulogise first of all the grand imposter who oversaw the final collapse of the Roman Republic, second to fabricate a fantastic lineage for the line of Caesar tracing him back to the defeated Trojans thereby copperfastening the final legitimation of an usurping imperial dynasty and thirdly to rid Roman arts and letters of that enormous 'cultural cringe' it had always felt towards the Greek world which had hitherto superseded it in so many domains.

The Aeneid really, to give it it's proper status is the product and consequence of a lapse into totalitarian autocratic government - which would have had many Roman die-hard republicans gasping for air like asphyxiated Orwellians; it oozes claustrophobic menace and chilly portents of the circus of corruption and venality which lay ahead. A most disturbing text indeed.
Gile na Gile is offline  
Old August 17th, 2012, 12:41 PM   #10

Clodius's Avatar
Theomachos
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 2,699
Blog Entries: 19

The Aeneid is not propaganda. It's full of ambiguity and sympathy for the victims of Roman "progress". Propaganda contains no ambiguity, and no sympathy for the victims.
Clodius is offline  
Reply

  Historum > World History Forum > Ancient History

Tags
aeneid, illiad, odyssey


Thread Tools
Display Modes


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Iliad & Odyssey CelticBard History Book Reviews 37 March 8th, 2013 09:16 AM
The Iliad vs The Odyssey Alcibiades Ancient History 50 March 2nd, 2013 03:26 AM
Was The Aeneid Complete? Kratos Ancient History 1 February 6th, 2010 11:57 AM
Happy Odyssey Lucius History Book Reviews 3 April 5th, 2009 08:14 AM
The Aeneid of Virgil fire_of_sekhmet History Book Reviews 4 September 9th, 2006 12:29 PM

Copyright © 2006-2013 Historum. All rights reserved.