Historum - History Forums  

Go Back   Historum - History Forums > World History Forum > Ancient History
Register Forums Blogs Social Groups Mark Forums Read

Ancient History Ancient History Forum - Greece, Rome, Carthage, Egypt, Mesopotamia, and all other civilizations of antiquity, to include Prehistory and Archaeology discussions


Reply
 
LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old January 13th, 2016, 01:34 AM   #11
Historian
 
Joined: Jan 2016
From: India
Posts: 1,637

Quote:
Originally Posted by PersianGirl View Post
Just let me remind you that Germanic languages are all derived from Persian Avestan and also the fact that Zoroaster composed the Gataha in Gothic language proves the fact that Gothic people were originally of Persian /Aryan stock.
This is very misleading and simply wrong.
German is a child of Proto-Germanic which is in turn a child of Proto-Indo-European. Avestan and German belong to 2 separate branches of Indo-European tree, and they are related only through a common ancestor, which is PIE. Believing that Avestan is an ancestor language of German is very funny.

Also, Zarathustra did not compose his Gathas in Gothic. He composed them in Old Avestan which was also his mother tongue.

Last edited by Bhrigu; January 13th, 2016 at 01:45 AM.
Bhrigu is offline  
Remove Ads
Old January 13th, 2016, 02:31 AM   #12

AlpinLuke's Avatar
Knight-errant
 
Joined: Oct 2011
From: Lago Maggiore, Italy
Posts: 22,674
Blog Entries: 19

Herodotus was talking about a local population [in Persia / Iran]. The name is a coincidence.

The Germanii he mentions inhabited the region of the satrapy called "Carmania" [or Karmania]

To know more I can mention: D. Asheri, commentary on Hdt. book 1; in A Commentary on Herodotus Books I-IV [Oxford, 2007] at p. 164; New Pauly s.v. "Carmania".
AlpinLuke is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 12:19 PM   #13

Matthew Amt's Avatar
Historian
 
Joined: Jan 2015
From: MD, USA
Posts: 2,545

Also, as I recall (and it's a little fuzzy!), there was no single tribe called "Germanii" in what we now call Germany. The general area was called Germania, and the Romans thought of the people as "Germans" in a collective way (similar to how many other cultures were "Celts"), but there were many different tribes under that umbrella.

They did have trousers, though...

Matthew
Matthew Amt is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 12:51 PM   #14
Historian
 
Joined: Jan 2010
From: -
Posts: 17,473

I feel as if I am back at All Empires History Forum
I'd wished I hadn't seen such claim again, Germans are Iranians, Saxons are Skythian....it is so sad, that such claims appear again and again.
beorna is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 12:54 PM   #15

Midas's Avatar
Γορδιεϝαις the Phrygian
 
Joined: Dec 2011
From: Scandinavia, Balkans, Anatolia, Hatay
Posts: 4,129
Blog Entries: 6

Quote:
Originally Posted by beorna View Post
I feel as if I am back at All Empires History Forum
I'd wished I hadn't seen such claim again, Germans are Iranians, Saxons are Skythian....it is so sad, that such claims appear again and again.
Cyrus Shahmiri's geist is in your room now...
Midas is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 12:56 PM   #16
Historian
 
Joined: Jan 2010
From: -
Posts: 17,473

Quote:
Originally Posted by Midas View Post
Cyrus Shahmiri's geist is in your room now...
I see, we suffered both.
beorna is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 02:40 PM   #17
Historian
 
Joined: Aug 2011
Posts: 4,513

Quote:
Originally Posted by Mnesiphilus View Post
Does anyone have a good explanation for the following excerpt from Herodotus' Histories?

Now, a large number of tribes go to make up the Persian race, and not all of them were convened by Cyrus and persuaded to rebel from Median rule— only those on whom all the other tribes depended, namely the Pasargadae, the Maraphians, and the Maspians. The Pasargadae are the noblest of these peoples and include the clan of the Achaemenidae, which provides Persia with its kings. The other Persian tribes are as follows: the Panthialaei, Derusiaei, and Germanii (who all work the land), and the Daļ, Mardians, Dropici, and Sagartians (who are nomadic). (Herodotus Ι – 125)
The Germanioi are Karmanians/Carmanians. GERMANIOI ? Encyclopaedia Iranica

It did lead to a German - Persian theory 1579-1602. Some still hang onto it.

Last edited by authun; January 13th, 2016 at 02:46 PM.
authun is offline  
Old January 13th, 2016, 04:34 PM   #18
Historian
 
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 6,008

Quote:
Originally Posted by PersianGirl View Post
Actually the fact that Herodotud knew the difference between different Indo-Iranian people is proven by his knowledge about the Scythians and Medes... ,

The Germanii clan were among the Persian tribes that Cyrus the great united against the Median confederation and they were Persian indeed, they still are , Germanii or Carmania is the ancient name of Kerman province and even today they are pure Persians .

Just let me remind you that Germanic languages are all derived from Persian Avestan and also the fact that Zoroaster composed the Gataha in Gothic language proves the fact that Gothic people were originally of Persian /Aryan stock .

This also explains Hitlers allance with Reza Shah (founder of the Pahlavi dynasty of Iran) , its said that even the re-naming of Persia into Iran( the land of Aryans) were suggested by Hitler himself .

The Germanii with two "i"s is not the same thing at the Germani with just one "i", although the words are spelled very similar. The Germani were a tribe in northern Gaul, in what is now considered to be Belgium. It is not clear what language the Germani spoke (the Belgic Celts claimed "German" descent, although the archaeological record show they spoke a Celtic language - perhaps the situation was similar to the later Franks, and Vikings, who although descended from Germanic speaking people, quickly adopted the language of the people they conquered.)

The Germanii tribe is located in a considerably different location, and since they are associated with Iranian language speaking people, probably spoke some kind of Iranian language. The "Germanii" and the "Germani" don't seem to be the same people, since their locations are so different, but just had similar sounding names. Keep in mind, the "Germani" name came from a Latin source, while the Germanii name came from a Greek source. It is probably just coincidence. There is for example, the Jewish tribe of Dan, and the New Guinea of the Dani, rather similar, but completely different people.

PS - As someone else also noted, "Germanic" languages are not descended from Persian, but are a considerably different branch of the Indo-European families of language from Persia. Celtic languages, Greek, and even Latin are all probably closer to Persian than any of the Germanic languages.

Last edited by Bart Dale; January 13th, 2016 at 04:40 PM.
Bart Dale is online now  
Old January 13th, 2016, 07:05 PM   #19
Historian
 
Joined: Sep 2014
From: Queens, NYC
Posts: 1,038

Apropos of the German/Persian language relation, it has been mentioned that the Ottomans, who used Persian as their "court language" (not law courts), viewed German as a corrupt form of Persian.
MJuingong is offline  
Old January 14th, 2016, 10:34 AM   #20
Historian
 
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 6,008

Quote:
Originally Posted by MJuingong View Post
Apropos of the German/Persian language relation, it has been mentioned that the Ottomans, who used Persian as their "court language" (not law courts), viewed German as a corrupt form of Persian.
Do you have any actual evidence that the Ottoman were so stupid to believe that?

It remains that German is vastly different from Persia and belong on a different branch on the IE languages. Persian is a Subject Object Verb language, while German is nominally a Subject Verb Object language, German has 3 grammatical genders, Persian none, Persian lacks definite articles for the most part, and the basic vocabulary, outside the common IE vocabulary, is different, and a host of other differences. IWhile the Ottomans weren't exactly rocket scientist outside of ways to kill, I can't believe the Ottomans were that bad of scholars..
Bart Dale is online now  
Reply

  Historum > World History Forum > Ancient History

Tags
germanii, persian, tribe



Search tags for this page
Thread Tools
Display Modes


Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
Did Greek play an important in making Old Persian to Middle Persian? SafavideIrani Middle Eastern and African History 7 October 20th, 2013 02:57 AM
Names of Median, Persian, and Parthian Rulers in OLD PERSIAN? AndreasK Ancient History 3 October 16th, 2013 03:12 PM
Non Persian Islamic conquerors spread Persian language more than pre Islamic Persia unity Middle Eastern and African History 54 September 9th, 2013 08:37 AM
Greco-Persian wars, Alexander etc - Persian perspective hist_man Ancient History 7 April 22nd, 2012 08:14 PM
Persian warfare--Use of elephants in Persian empire Iloveelephants Ancient History 5 February 5th, 2012 10:54 PM

Copyright © 2006-2013 Historum. All rights reserved.