 | | General History General History Forum - General history questions and discussions |
May 23rd, 2012, 10:38 AM
|
#81 | | Historian
Joined: Apr 2010 Posts: 1,320 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Pavel No, when one nation infringes and derogates rights of other nations.But if government bestows equal rights to every citizens(not necessary democratic), refrains from discrimination,it has right to exist. | So you wouldn't mind if Russia was completely occupied by for example the US, as long as the Russians were given equal rights and were not treated any differently? To you national pride and self determination doesn't matter?
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 11:03 AM
|
#82 | | Revisionist
Joined: Nov 2011 From: Closer to Calais than to Birmingham Posts: 3,635 | Quote:
Originally Posted by General Michael Collins | Irish Banker counting his six-figure bonus?
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 01:11 PM
|
#83 | | Suspended indefinitely
Joined: Oct 2010 Posts: 870 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Krystian So you wouldn't mind if Russia was completely occupied by for example the US, as long as the Russians were given equal rights and were not treated any differently? To you national pride and self determination doesn't matter? |
If one nation allows the other nation to take over, then it is in agreement with what is happening to it.
If a nation doesn't like the situation, it fights back.
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 01:12 PM
|
#84 | | Lecturer
Joined: May 2012 From: San Diego, CA Posts: 322 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Krystian | I think all of those nations should pray the god that they weren't forced to get assimilated . All european empires assimilated people who they conquered. I also don't believe Armenian genocide, Ottoman Empire did not have power to do a 'genocide' at 1915. Armenians joined the war on the Russian side and they got defeated. I believe more Turkish civilians died in WW1 and independence war then Armenian civilians.
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 02:48 PM
|
#85 | | Historian
Joined: Nov 2009 From: ϧϣҩɻƣ Posts: 2,025 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Vezir I think all of those nations should pray the god that they weren't forced to get assimilated . All european empires assimilated people who they conquered. I also don't believe Armenian genocide, Ottoman Empire did not have power to do a 'genocide' at 1915. Armenians joined the war on the Russian side and they got defeated. I believe more Turkish civilians died in WW1 and independence war then Armenian civilians. | Riddicolous.
Those nation were invade and Turkish were invaders, that's the point.
Turkish civilians died, because the inept Young Turks embarked themselves upon a war they had no chance to win.
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 03:04 PM
|
#86 | | Historian
Joined: Sep 2010 Posts: 2,960 |
Not in my opinion.
. I wonder how many citizens of conquered,colonised and annexed countries thought "Ah well, no better than we deserved"
Sounds like a rather self serving and smug justification for the strong stomping on the weak,as tends to be the case with countries.
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 04:27 PM
|
#87 | | Historian
Joined: Apr 2010 Posts: 1,320 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Vezir I think all of those nations should pray the god that they weren't forced to get assimilated . All european empires assimilated people who they conquered. I also don't believe Armenian genocide, Ottoman Empire did not have power to do a 'genocide' at 1915. Armenians joined the war on the Russian side and they got defeated. I believe more Turkish civilians died in WW1 and independence war then Armenian civilians. | The European colonizers managed to assimilate only primitive, stone-age societies. When a European power took over another European nation's land it didn't manage to do that. The Spanish controlled the Netherlands but didn't turn the Dutch into Spanish did they? That's because those people were already Christian and European - it's much harder, almost impossible, to assimilate people of the same civilization group. Even when muslim states were colonized, like Algiers by the French for example, they couldn't assimilate or convert them. It only works with primitive, extremely different societies that had no previous contact with that civilization - like the native americans, africans or some isolated east asians (Philippines). If the Balkan people were conquered by a European empire they would not get assimilated.
However, had any European power taken over the Balkans instead of the Ottomans then all of Europe's progress would flow to the Balkans immediately. The Balkan nations would not have their Rennaissance in the 19th century, but in the 16th, along with the rest of Europe. They would not be influenced culturally by Orientalism either. They would not be divided by Islamizations, as in the case of the Bosniaks, Pomaks, Albanians etc. Of course, the best option for them would be to remain independent and flourish as they did before and after the ottoman occupation, but if a takeover had to be chose, a European/Christian one is in any case better than Ottoman/Oriental/Muslim one.
About the Armenians i don't want to enter a pointless debate, suffice it to say the Turks did massacre Armenians at least as much as Vlad Tepes massacred Turks (he actually massacred more non-turks). So if your logic says Ottoman rule over Wallachia is deserved because of Tepes' massacres, than an Armenian rule over Turkey is just as much if not more deserved for their suffering (which even without a genocide of 1.5 million is surely large).
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 04:38 PM
|
#88 | | Suspended indefinitely
Joined: Oct 2010 Posts: 870 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Vezir Armenians joined the war on the Russian side and they got defeated. | Without even going into the subject of who, when and where...
How could Armenia "join" Russian side, if Armenia was PART OF the Russian Empire?! Can you say Bedfordshire joined Britain in WW1?
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 04:44 PM
|
#89 | | Scholar
Joined: Oct 2011 Posts: 980 |
One example immediately springs to mind: North Korea deserves to be conquered and ruled by South Korea.
| | |
| |
May 23rd, 2012, 05:53 PM
|
#90 | | Historian
Joined: Sep 2010 Posts: 2,960 | Quote:
Originally Posted by Fox One example immediately springs to mind: North Korea deserves to be conquered and ruled by South Korea. | No country deserves to be conquered;it is the innocent who always suffer the most
Dictatorships ALWAYS fall eventually, as does every powerful system or country.
| | |
| | | Thread Tools | | | | Display Modes | Linear Mode |
Copyright © 2006-2013 Historum. All rights reserved.
|  |