Historum - History Forums  

Go Back   Historum - History Forums > Themes in History > History in Films and on Television
Register Forums Blogs Social Groups Mark Forums Read

History in Films and on Television History in Films and on TV - Documentary Films, Historical Dramas, and history programs on PBS and the History Channel

LinkBack Thread Tools Display Modes
Old December 31st, 2016, 12:05 PM   #1
Joined: May 2011
From: New Iberia, La.
Posts: 312
NOW SHOWING: Rogue One (2016)

Click the image to open in full size.

Usually when a new war movie is released, I try to get to the theater as soon as possible to review it so all my fans (both of them) will know whether to go see it. In this case, I waited until everyone else in the country had seen it. The reason is I had a gut reaction against it. After having been burned by all the Star Wars movies since the second one, I was not exactly going to camp out over night for this one. The belatedness was not due to it not being a war movie. While certainly firmly in the sci-fi genre, it does fit secondarily into the war genre. In the future, I will be compiling my top ten sci-fi war movies. (One of many projects that will keep me semi-retired.) Let’s see if this one will make the list.

“Rogue One: A Star Wars Story” is the first in a proposed trilogy of Star Wars stand-alones. Someone at Lucasfilms had a discussion with their boss and convinced him that although the last five Star Wars films were fantastic and not at all pieces of ****, maybe a different approach might be fun. Coppola bought it, thankfully. Gareth Edwards was tabbed to direct and he decided to develop immediate good will from the non-Koolaid drinkers by jettisoning the opening crawl that even people from Outer Mongolia associate with Star Wars movies. He got the green light to populate the movie with two outstanding actors and the ghost of another and then fill in the cast with unknowns. And most importantly, he decided to Hell with four year olds. Sorry Jar Jar Binks and Ewoks fans.

The movie opens on some backwoods planet named “who cares?” Galen Erso (Mads Mikkelson) is a genius scientist who is needed by an evil less genius scientist named Orson Krennic (Ben Mendelsohn) to finish their big project – a weapon that can destroy planets. Galen has been hiding for years, but Hollywood finds him. In the process, his daughter Jyn decides to postpone her well-rehearsed escape long enough to see Krennic kill her mother. Revenge motive established, the movie jumps fifteen years. Fifteen years of feist-developing. She is rescued from a labor camp because the rebel Alliance needs her to make contact with her father. A defector pilot named Bodhi Rook (Riz Ahmed) has been sent by Galen to clue them in on a weakness in the Death Star he has helped Krennic complete. A hot shot rebel named Sans Holo, actually Cassian Andor (Diego Luna), and his wise-cracking robot K-2SO (think C3PO with a ‘tude) are to accompany Jyn (Felicity Jones) on a mission to locate her father. Cassian has the corollary secret order to eliminate Galen. Their stop at Jehda City results in a nifty bout of urban combat, but the end result is not positive for Jehda City. Evil weapons gotta be tested. On the plus side, the massive explosion sets Jyn and her rapidly growing gang of rogues free from internment. (I hope the screenwriters feel guilty about this plot device.) Now it’s off to Eadu to rescue Daddy (or assassinate him). When they return, the rebel council has a decision to make. With the threat of the Death Star confirmed, some want to cave and others want to go down in a blaze of glory. Although the comments are divided evenly between the wimps and the kamikazes, the tribal council decides to surrender without a vote. This is in spite of a spirited call to arms by Jyn. She does convince some of the braves to leave the reservation to kick and receive kicked asses. And get the plans to the Death Star. It’s a suicide mission behind enemy lines – did I mention it’s a war movie? Our original motley crew is supplemented by some nameless (the screenwriters having run out of super cool names) equivalents of Colonial Marines (“Aliens” reference). What follows is a mash-up of the Battle of Leyte Gulf, the Battle of Britain, Omaha Beach, and the Raid on Telemark. And Hiroshima. Something for everyone (above the age of four) – sabotage, espionage, dog fights, infantry vs. tanks, ships colliding, etc. The tactics are acceptable, considering Dale Dye was not on the set. The screenwriters must have researched the Battle off Samar and copied the moment when a tug boat was used to shove the Nagato into the Yamato.

In an interview, Edwards stated that he looked upon the project as a war movie. He was not kidding. It has elements of several war subgenres. It appears that if you want to combine those subgenres into entertainment that does not defy reality, you can set it in a galaxy far, far away. Ironically, the movie actually starts with a standard Western trope. The old “you killed my ma” theme. The main template is the motley band on a quest. The core unit is heterogeneous, naturally. (But no one is from Brooklyn.) This includes the hot shot, the feisty female, the spiritual blind monk, his Vikingish mercenary buddy, and the wise cracking robot. I have to admit I am a sucker for these quest groups. And I have learned to not get too attached to the members. I advise the same to you. Don’t expect some dysfunctionality. The film is all black or white, there are no greys. Speaking of black, the villains are worthy of the white hats. Darth Vader has his best performance since “Empire”. The movie makes perfect use of him. It is not a stunt like you would have expected. But even the stunts work. Peter Cushing’s face appears as Governor Tarkin. Before you overdose on umbrage, it is amazingly seamless. Spoiler alert: Cushing has been dead since 1994. Normally I would make a crack about his winning the acting honors, but the living cast is good, too. Felicity Jones is great as Jyn. She and the rest of the heroes should be in for some big pay days in the sequels. (Those of you who have seen the movie will be laughing at that prediction.) For you war movie fanatics, that’s Jiang Wen of “Devils on the Doorstep” as the bearish Blaze Malbus (who wins name honors). He and the others make you forget that the two real actors (Mads Mikkelson and Forest Whitaker) are barely used. Maybe they will have bigger roles in the next film.

“Rogue One” is an outstanding movie. If not for nostalgia and the desire to not get beaten up by a mob of pocket-protecting geeks, I might argue that it is the best Star Wars movie. It is undoubtedly better than all but “New Hope” and “Empire” and much better than the last one. It does not pander to its audience. The nods to the other films are subtle and not ham-fisted like in “The Force Awakens”. The closing scene is a perfect lead in to “A New Hope”. If you ever wondered “who had to die to get those plans?”, now you’ll know. But it’s the action that will be remembered. The last half hour has everything but the kitchen sink thrown in (and blown up). The film manages to intercut between the “naval battle”, the ground support air battle, the foot soldiers, and the infiltration. You’ll wish you had Saw Gerrera’s air tank.

warmoviebuff is offline  
Remove Ads
Old January 2nd, 2017, 11:31 PM   #2

homewrecker's Avatar
Joined: Oct 2014
From: Southern California
Posts: 23

That's a great review. I saw it and I must say I was quite pleased. I agree, the last 30 minutes was outstanding. Also, the CGI of characters last seen in form 40 years was great, and at times I forgot they we're CGI. Finally a decent prequel was created for this franchise. Great movie.

Sent from my LG-LS997 using Tapatalk
homewrecker is offline  
Old January 3rd, 2017, 07:30 AM   #3

Matthew Amt's Avatar
Joined: Jan 2015
From: MD, USA
Posts: 2,419

Agreed, great movie and great review! I kept looking at Tarkin, not knowing that Peter Cushing was dead but definitely sure that he couldn't actually look like that any more, and trying to figure out if it was CGI or just a really well-done look-alike actor! Pretty impressive.

The big explosions from the Death Star shots were FABULOUS. The second one especially was taken directly from a nuclear test in the Pacific back in the 50's or 60's, very well done. (Well, the first one went on a little long and slow, but that was for *effect*!)

And yes, the Rebel infantry actually looked like they knew what they were doing, aside from the insanely short engagement ranges (again, very Star Wars!).

But talk about innovation: Vader in a shower scene! My hero.

Matthew Amt is online now  
Old January 4th, 2017, 09:59 AM   #4
Joined: Oct 2014
From: California, USA
Posts: 129


It was a movie about hope where all the main characters died...and actually managed to pull that that off well. I felt it was deeper than some of the others...really focusing on the sacrifices people in the rebellion made, and the hard choices. Yes, definitely a war movie. I was surprised and impressed.

ecarian is offline  
Old January 4th, 2017, 05:09 PM   #5

Congo's Avatar
Joined: Apr 2010
From: USA
Posts: 2,486

A bizarre movie.

Huge amounts of complete boredom the first two acts and then an unbelievable third act. So much so, that I want to watch it all over again and enjoy the first two acts since I realize what will be happening.
Congo is offline  
Old January 10th, 2017, 06:12 AM   #6
Joined: Dec 2016
From: UK
Posts: 196

I think Rogue one had a lot more epic battles compared to the Force awakens, when vader showed up at the end he really stole the show.
TheMilitaryHistoryAddict is offline  

  Historum > Themes in History > History in Films and on Television

2016, rogue, showing

Thread Tools
Display Modes

Similar Threads
Thread Thread Starter Forum Replies Last Post
NOW SHOWING: Hacksaw Ridge (2016) warmoviebuff History in Films and on Television 24 July 31st, 2017 11:42 AM
NOW SHOWING: Allied (2016) warmoviebuff History in Films and on Television 4 November 28th, 2016 10:19 AM
NOW SHOWING: Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk (2016) warmoviebuff History in Films and on Television 0 November 22nd, 2016 06:13 PM
The Rogue Republic Knarly Dan American History 0 April 28th, 2011 01:37 PM
Israel, ROGUE STATE corrocamino Middle Eastern and African History 136 July 2nd, 2010 06:44 AM

Copyright © 2006-2013 Historum. All rights reserved.