Political decisions and chronic pain

Joined Mar 2015
2,804 Posts | 702+
Europe
How much comment is there about temper and politically important decisions of politically important persons afflicted by chronic pain due to various health conditions?
This:
discusses the leg ulcers of Henry VIII.
A conclusion giving 2 other cases:
Persistent chronic leg ulcers have been shown to seriously adversely affect quality of life even in the age of modern medical treatment and analgesia.17 For Henry, racked with pain and repetitive infection, his ulcers regularly cauterized with red-hot irons, the situation must have been intolerable. The effect of chronic pain on the temperament is well recognized and the actions of many a historical figure have been linked to their personal physical misery. Judge Jeffries (1645–1689), widely known as the ‘Hanging Judge’ for his merciless punishment of King James II's enemies after the Monmouth Rebellion, was reputed to be in such a foul temper because of the bladder stones bouncing up and down on his trigone while travelling to the Bloody Assizes in a poorly-sprung carriage over potholed roads;18 and Napoleon Bonaparte's painful haemorrhoids left him sullen and quick to anger, unable to survey his troops by horseback at the Battle of Waterloo.19 Henry's vile temper was undoubtedly influenced by his clinical situation. Although he did not bear his suffering with fortitude, and his latter years were characterized by frequent tempestuous rages and cruelty, viciously turning on those that he had once patronised, he was courageous in his refusal to lie a-bed, allowing a fleeting glimpse of the valiant prince he used to be.
Any other notable cases?
 
  • Like
Reactions: NordicDemosthenes
Joined Apr 2018
3,115 Posts | 1,300+
Paeania
How much comment is there about temper and politically important decisions of politically important persons afflicted by chronic pain due to various health conditions?
This:
discusses the leg ulcers of Henry VIII.
A conclusion giving 2 other cases:

Any other notable cases?
Quite a lot of Kings in the 1500s and so on had similar issues to Henry VIII. Gustav Vasa in Sweden didn’t really have any teeth left by the time of his third marriage at 50, going around with chronic mouth pain can’t exactly be nice.

Of course, maybe sometimes chronic pain hardens and strengthens the character? At least if it starts early. Augustus was sickly, but apparently good at coping with it.

I think there are probably a lot of parallells, spiritually, between chronic pain and politics: it is a never-ending struggle, interruped by short periods of glory or numbness maybe. It’s also often ends very unsatisfying in a lot of ways for most statesmen, as almost always the dreams they had become if not totally unrealized then at least not feeling as good once realized as one might have imagined. You need a particular kind of mentality to be successfull in all of this, and I think having lots of chronic pain from childhood is probably one of the best schools for getting you into the right psychology.

Maybe the problem with Henry VIII was that he had been physically strong and vivacious when young, so when he got lots of chronic illnesses in middle age that had a particularly nasty effect on his character?
 
Joined Feb 2024
32 Posts | 8+
c h lvlucu
I mean Richard III suffered from scholiosis right, even if he didn't specifically have anything to do with the Princess in the Tower, he still had a pretty nasty rap sheet
 
Joined Jul 2015
16,914 Posts | 9,355+
Netherlands
JFK apparently was doped up to combat chronic pain.
Might explain some of his decisions with regards to Cuba for example.
 
Joined Sep 2012
10,340 Posts | 4,400+
Bulgaria
The assassination attempt on Lenin in 1918 had a serious impact on his health and physical activity. The second bullet had no serious consequences, however, the first one caused irreparable damage. The neck of the femur, where the bullet entered, was severely damaged, which caused problems with walking, so he had to use a cane. His health subsequently continued to deteriorate, he experienced severe pain and was forced to spend much time in bed or in a wheelchair. As a result of the assassination attempt, Lenin suffered a disability that severely limited his physical activity. He suffered from multiple nervous disorders and was subject to a series of heart attacks. However he was politically active till 1922, held meetings and wrote his works.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheBlackPrince
Joined Sep 2012
10,340 Posts | 4,400+
Bulgaria
It should be noted that in 1921 the headaches & loss of ability to work bothered Lenin greatly. During this period he told Stalin that he would probably end up with paralysis and made Stalin promise that in this case he would help him get potassium cyanide. Lenin suffered his first stroke in May 1922. The illness progressed unevenly, there were short remissions, followed by deteriorations. He suffered a second stroke followed by right sided paralysis in December 1922. Despite his condition, he continued to dictate notes and articles on party affairs. Lenin asked again and again for poison in order to commit suicide, alas in vain, and in March 1923, a third stroke followed, which left him speechless vegetable, although he lived for another ten months.
 
  • Interesting
Reactions: TheBlackPrince
Joined Mar 2015
2,804 Posts | 702+
Europe
Lenin suffered his first stroke in May 1922. The illness progressed unevenly, there were short remissions, followed by deteriorations. He suffered a second stroke followed by right sided paralysis in December 1922. Despite his condition, he continued to dictate notes and articles on party affairs. Lenin asked again and again for poison in order to commit suicide, alas in vain, and in March 1923, a third stroke followed, which left him speechless vegetable, although he lived for another ten months.
No, Lenin was NOT a vegetable in 1923-1924.
By May, he appeared to be making a slow recovery, regaining some of his mobility, speech, and writing skills.
"Some" mobility and speech skills, but in the ten months, far from enough to consistently and clearly communicate and be relied on to tell others what to do.
Note the irregular timing of the first three strokes. May 1922, then 7 months to second stroke in December, then 3 months to third stroke in March, then no fourth stroke for 10 months.
Details of recovery of "vegetable" (so called by a number of sources, not blaming you personally):
Soon he began to walk with assistance. In the beginning of August he commenced exercises for the restoration of speech. Lenin was so much better that Rozanov, as he writes in his memoirs, went on a month’s vacation.
Lenin now objected to medicines, drove away the nurses, and refused to be examined by the physicians.
In September the doctors, aided by shoemakers, fitted Lenin with orthopedic shoes and he started to walk in his room using a cane for support. The next month he showed further improvement. Krupskaya, with infinite patience, tried to teach him to utter a few simple words. He looked at the newspaper and indicated the items he wanted read to him.
While Skvortsov-Stepanov told Lenin about the elections to the Moscow Soviet he paid little attention and looked at books lying on the table. But when the visitor mentioned the extension of streetcar service to the outlying proletarian wards of the city and the closing of beer saloons, Lenin “began to listen attentively” and uttered “the only word he had mastered well: ‘Vot, vot,’ ”"—That’s it, that’s it.
In October...
The same month he began, with great difficulty, to write with his left hand.
That´s about as far as Lenin´s recovery got. No longer bedridden or wheelchair "bound", starting to walk with a cane 6 months after getting wheelchair bound, mastering only one word reliably, writing "with great difficulty", communicating some understanding of what he saw and what was told him.
 
  • Like
Reactions: At Each Kilometer
Joined Oct 2011
40,550 Posts | 7,631+
Italy, Lago Maggiore
Hitler ...
he suffered a lot.
He suffered from toothache for substantially his all life ...
It seems that when he died he had only four teeth which were still sane ...

Not to forget all the other pains. His gastritis was chronicle.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TheBlackPrince
Joined Nov 2010
14,406 Posts | 4,143+
Cornwall
I mean Richard III suffered from scholiosis right, even if he didn't specifically have anything to do with the Princess in the Tower, he still had a pretty nasty rap sheet

Who was this Princess?

Anyway, how about Napoleon? His various ailments, like being unable to pee, allegedly, causing great pain, must have affected his judgement in the last, catastrophic years.
 

Trending History Discussions

Top