war

  1. Commodus

    Favorite Civil War story?

    The American Civil War is an incredibly interesting time in history, full of big personalities and big leaps in warfare - from tactics to the technology armies used. And as it's a subject of such interest to this forum, and so many of you are very learned on the issue, I thought it would be nice...
  2. EmperorTigerstar

    The Battle for the Indian Ocean

    Might as well make the first thread for this new section. So one thing that I think is simultaneously interesting but overlooked is the battle for trade in the Indian Ocean. The Indian Ocean, being the smallest non-polar ocean, is usually not discussed as much compared to the Atlantic and...
  3. Dose

    What historically-considered war atrocities do you think were justified?

    I'm unsure myself but I'm very open to hearing different views on this topic.
  4. Darth Raidius

    No western involvement in the Soviet-Afghan war

    What if, during the Soviet-Afghan war of 1979-1989, the United States and other involved western countries were led by sane leaders that staunchly refused to support the Afghan Mujahideen? How differently would the Soviets fare in Afghanistan? And should the Soviets emerge victorious, how would...
  5. Futurist

    A restoration of the French monarchy after a French defeat in WWI?

    If France lost World War I, would there have been a realistic chance of the French monarchy being restored? For the record, I am thinking of France losing World War I due to British neutrality in this war. Of course, this might require a somewhat later World War I--perhaps one which breaks out...
  6. sparky

    the inevitable road to war

    . Wars happen , Clausewitz held war to be a continuum of politics using other means as the relations between the US and Russia grow from bad to worst ,the internal politics of both become fevered , various factions plunging into a self inflating hysteria in a feedback loop It seems...
  7. M

    Infantry battles in the Gulf War?

    How common where infantry battles in the Gulf War? I am reading about 73 Easting and I believe there was times the US tanks units got bumrushed by Iraqi infantry only to be driven back to Bradleys and airstrikes.
  8. M

    Advanced Allied Military Technology (Secret Weapons) in World War 2

    In World War 2 literature a lot of things were written , researched about superior German military technology or Secret Weapons like V-1 flying bombs , V-2 ballistic missiles , ME262 jet fighters and other jet engine propelled aircraft models , remote controlled tanks , hydrogen peroksite...
  9. jameen

    Second Sino-Japan War w/o US participation of World War 2

    Do you think Japan can invade and rule China like the Mongols if ever the US did not go to war because Japan never bombed Pearl Harbor?
  10. Millennium 7

    Grand Strategy in the American Civil War

    I have an impression, when it comes to strategy in the ACW: that there was none. The famous Anaconda plan was first rejected than, in practice, piecemeal adopted by the Union. Lincoln seems to have been driven by the necessity of "showing something" at the next political appointment. The...
  11. Darth Raidius

    What territories did Germany intend to keep after World War II?

    Had the Axis won at least some kind of victory in World War II, retaining all their occupied territories, how would Hitler reshape the borders of Europe? What nations would he keep and integrate as German territories, what nations would he release as puppet governments, and which (if any) would...
  12. I

    Looking for books about Austrian Succession War

    I am not historian but 18th century military history fascinates me, especially in Europe. Can you recommend me please a good book covering Austrian Succession War and if possible any of its battles: Fontenoy, Dettingen, Bassignana?
  13. Darth Raidius

    If the Axis remained in the Cold War, who would align with them?

    In an alternate history scenario where World War II ended in a stalemate, and the Cold War was fought between three ideologies instead of two (capitalism, communism and now also fascism), what world leaders would align with the Axis rather than the other two? Francisco Franco of Spain is an...
  14. D

    War of Souabe (1499)

    Hello everybody.I am looking for the best book about the war of Souabe (1499) between the switzerland confederation and the german league of Souabe.Thank you.
  15. B

    What was the size of the various factions during the Spanish Civil War?

    What was the size of the various factions during the Spanish Civil War, 1936-1939 (e.g., CNT, Popular Front, Falange, Carlists)? Ideally if possible there sizes at different points in the war.
  16. I

    How were the infantry tactics during First World War?

    I am not familiar with First World War tactics. I can get an idea from Port Arthur siege in Russo-Japanese War (1904-05) were mass of japanese soldiers were sent to russian fortifications and also from Franco-Prussian War (18070-71) but the extensive use of Trench Warfare may have changed the...
  17. Dios

    Faked 1860-1940 Era Photos: Pterosaurs/Pteranodons/Thunderbirds

    Does anyone know the story behind these? I'm not a photo analyst. Some of these are fakes. Why would anyone bother to do that? Is there a story? Let's presume they're ALL fakes. What's the motivation? Selling the photos at a premium? There are more pics .......
  18. E

    Does it posibble to find a war diary of a army division?

    Now I am studying about the first persian gulf war. and hope to know the movement of every unit (division level). Such as After US attack start, what is the position of 101 airbone division every day? So I can make a detailed map of the war to realize it. Anyone can provide any information...
  19. Visigoth Panzer

    Shotel a Weapon of War?

    The Shotel (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shotel) was an Ethiopian double-edged curved sword that could be used to slash around an opponents shield. It was said the elite warriors that used it could employ it on foot and horseback. An article I read said when Europeans first came to east Africa...
  20. Futurist

    Before World War I, did most Slovenians want a federal unit within Austria-Hungary?

    It states in this Wikipedia article that the idea of a United Slovenia--specifically the idea that Slovenia should be an autonomous, federal unit within the Austrian Empire--was a popular idea among Slovenes in the pre-World War I decades. Anyway, is this true? Was this genuinely what most...