America's Greatest General?

[Marius]

Who is the greatest general the United States ever produced?

 

[Americanfighter]

you forgot Sherman.

 

[fledse]

My vote was for McArthur.

 

[mlipo]

you forgot Sherman.

That's what "other" is for...

 

[wittgenstein]

Generals never do anything in particular, they leave that to the grunts.I remember, a great general store in Wisconsin. I told the owner," I love your store but you do not sell anything in particular!

 

[mlipo]

Generals never do anything in particular, they leave that to the grunts.

Do you actually believe that, or are you still recovering from the naked girl/unicorn thread?

 

[avon]

ROFL

 

[Heidi XX]

My vote goes to Dwight "IKE" Einsenhower.

Patton was good, but all he wanted to do is beat the English and not worry about the Germans,while IKE was intented to have his eyes on the germans and not his fellow mates.

 

[Richard Stanbery]

I voted for Jackson. In many ways he was the polar opposite of (edited) Albert Pike. I think that if he would have survived the war and the South had won, then Jackson would have dealt with Pike. Imagine the next Confederate election, with the Lee/ Jackson tickett. Who could have stood against him?

 

[mlipo]

I voted for Jackson. In many ways he was the polar opposite of Alexander Pike. I think that if he would have survived the war and the South had won, then Jackson would have dealt with Pike. Imagine the next Confederate election, with the Lee/ Jackson tickett. Who could have stood against him?

Who the hell is Alexander Pike?