Aryan counterattack hypothesis

Status
Closed

specul8

Ad Honorem
Oct 2016
3,690
Australia
For a person versed in this matter, these facts are self-evident. Which of the theses dobtful for you? I will prove everything that is listed based on real sources, not on “textbooks” and “studies”, but on real historical monuments
Then, go ahead now ; prove everything you listed, based on real sources, not on “textbooks” and “studies”, but on real historical monuments.

.... waiting .....
 

deaf tuner

Ad Honoris
Oct 2013
15,022
Europix
For a person versed in this matter, these facts are self-evident. Which of the theses dobtful for you? I will prove everything that is listed based on real sources, not on “textbooks” and “studies”, but on real historical monuments
"Dubito, ergo cogito". I doubt a lot, until I see proofs. And even then.

Especially on history, especial these days, I totally distrust faith, it's only critical thinking that might help.

I personally can't wait for sources: it's an interesting subject.
 
Jun 2019
350
ru
I personally can't wait for sources: it's an interesting subject.
I start with the last thesis

"The system of moral of Aryans not agressive, mythologia talks about defence from enslavers of cows, waters and people, meet-eaters, cunning snake and so on."

Through him lying like a reed cut
Water flows, rolls. Manu.
Vritra once bound them with its size, -
Now a dragon lay at their feet.
---------


You knocked down witch Shushnu.
The wise know this about you.
Raise their glory!

_____

With the help of light, he pulled cows out of the darkness.

From Rigveda.

4.36 Against demons and other enemies

1.
Agni Vaishwanara, strong in truth
Bull, burn those
Who wants to harm us and harm us
And also those who want to undress us!

2.
Who wants to hurt us when we don’t want to hurt
And who wants to hurt when we want to hurt
Togo I'm planting right
On two fangs of Agni Vaishwanara.

3.
Who, boastfully calling to each other,
Hunts on the night of the new moon
Meat-eaters who want to harm others
I master all of them by force.

4.
I master writing power.
I take away their wealth
I kill everyone who wants to do evil
May my intention come true!

Athharvaveda

Is it enough?
 
Last edited:
Mar 2018
1,034
UK
. . .

If you actually think that this is *proof* that the Aryans had a peaceful, non-aggressive culture then you need to revisit the definition of proof.

If after doing that you still don't get it, then I don't think there's anything that anyone on this forum can do for you.
 

Edratman

Forum Staff
Feb 2009
6,847
Eastern PA
Thread closed.

OP altered the text of a quote in post #3 earning a permanent ban and the thread will accompany him.

The Mod Team
 
  • Like
Reactions: specul8
Status
Closed