Battle of Brawner's Farm- Stonewall meets the Iron Brigade

Viperlord

Ad Honorem
Aug 2010
8,109
VA


The opening clash in the Second Battle of Manassas erupted on August 28th. The ailing Rufus King's division of Federal troops was marching along the Warrenton Turnpike, bound for Centreville, where Union Maj. Gen. John Pope, commanding officer of the Army of Virginia, believed Stonewall Jackson's men to be located. In fact, Jackson and his veteran divisions were lurking on Stony Ridge, almost on top of their old battleground at First Manassas. Jackson, now aware that Longstreet and Lee were approaching Thoroughfare Gap and would soon be able to join him, was now looking for an opportunity to attack, rather than continue to avoid Pope. He now had such an opportunity, as King's lone division was now marching right into his grasp. Jackson planned an immediate attack near Groveton; he deployed the Stonewall division, commanded by William B. Taliaferro, and Ewell's division into position to attack when he gave the signal. A.P. Hill's division was some distance behind the other divisions, in reserve. The leading brigade of King's division, commanded by John P. Hatch, scouted the area, encountering only a few Confederate horsemen, and moved on. John Gibbon's green western brigade, known as the Black Hat Brigade for their regular-army style headgear, were next in line.

As Gibbon's men advanced, Gibbon himself noticed Confederate horsemen moving out of the timber to his north. He saw them turning, presenting their flanks. Gibbon, an artillerist in the regular army who wrote an artillery manual before the war, recognized that guns were coming into battery and preparing to fire on his men. He promptly ordered up his own artillery batter, Battery B, which he himself had once commanded, to return fire, while his lead regiment, the Sixth Wisconsin, took cover from the Confederate fire. Another Confederate battery had opened fire in the meantime. Gibbon believed that he was dealing with horse artillery, since Hatch's men had scouted the area previously. He sent the Second Wisconsin forward to deal with the guns, leading them personally part of the way. The regiment encountered skirmishers who abruptly opened fire into the regiment's right flank. This would have been enough to give pause to many green regiments, but not the Badgers on this day. They wheeled about and quickly drove back the skirmishers. The Confederate Stonewall Brigade, 800 strong, appeared on the left flank of the Second at this point, and opened fire with a fury. Again, the Second Wisconsin reacted like veterans, partially wheeling about again and returning fire. Gibbon promptly called up the Nineteenth Indiana to hold the Second's left, and they advanced to meet the Stonewall brigade, blasting away with a fury. More Confederate regiments began to open fire , and realizing this was no isolated detachment, Gibbon called for help from the rest of the division.

The weight of the Confederate assault was coming on Gibbon's right, and Gibbon sent his last regiments, the Sixth and Seventh Wisconsin, to the right. Arriving simultaneously, the regiments encountered the leading elements of Ewell's division, and forcefully drove their veteran opponents back. The veteran Confederates, upon being reinforced, quickly advanced again, and now the battle was joined on open ground. Gibbon's flanks were in the air, and there was a gap between his two regiments on the left, and the two on the right. Gibbon had 2,100 men in his brigade against 5,200 Confederates in four brigades, and with plenty more on the way. The Confederates put in three artillery batteries against Gibbon's Battery B; however, the Federal battery got the best of the artillery duel, and the Confederate guns were shifted to provide enfilade fire against the infantry, to little effect in the close range engagement. Meanwhile, Gibbon's calls for help weren't completely unanswered; Doubleday promptly sent two of his three regiments to Gibbon's assistance, increasing Gibbon's total force to 2,900 and later followed up with the third. His regiments filled the gap in Gibbon's center. Patrick's brigade was further back, and for some reason did not move to the front particularly quickly. Hatch's brigade had been too far in the advance; Hatch started back when he heard the guns, but arrived too late to be engaged.

Meanwhile, Jackson and Gibbon's regiments engaged in a brutal stand-up fight of close-range volleys. Jackson attempted to deploy more men, but failed to get most of them into the battle before the fall of darkness. Ewell and Taliaferro, commanding the two divisions engaged, were both shot during the battle, as were several brigade and regimental commanders, impacting command and control. Jackson attempted to throw in regiments himself piecemeal, largely to little effect as the nature of the terrain slowed down additional deployments. The battle was ended up by darkness and the implicit consent of Gibbon and his Confederate opposites; as darkness fell, his troops withdrew a short distance to better cover, and the Confederates held their ground. Confederate Taliaferro, who remained on the field despite his injuries, later remarked "It was a question of endurance, and both sides endured."

The casualties were appalling on both sides. Gibbon lost between 700 and 800 casualties, or slightly over a third of his command. Seven of his twelve field officers were killed or injured. Doubleday's men, although latecomers, fought nearly as hard, losing 160 casualties, bringing the Union total to approximately 900-950 of the 2,900 men engaged. However, the Federals inflicted even worse casualties on their Confederate opposites. Trimble's brigade of 1200 lost approximately 750 men as casualties. The Sixth Wisconsin, which fought Lawton's brigade essentially on it's own, albeit in better cover than any other unit in the engagement, lost 72 men while taking down about 420 of Lawton's men. The Stonewall Brigade lost 340 men out of their 800. Other Confederate casualties brought the total to around 2,000.

Jackson's trap had largely misfired. He gained nothing other than a bloody nose for his trouble in engaging King's Division, and he had revealed his position to Pope's army before Longstreet was in supporting distance, a dangerous move that would draw Pope into the Battle of Second Manassas. With the element of surprise and a vastly numerically superior force in terms of the troops engaged, 6,000 veteran troops to under 3,000 green Federals, he had failed to achieve anything other than stalemate. King and his officers met to discuss what to do next; the brigadiers, Gibbon included, prudently advocated withdrawal of the seemingly isolated division. But what King failed to mention to his officers was that he had met with John Reynolds, who also commanded a division at this time. Reynolds had agreed to bring up his division to join King in the morning. If King had stood firm, the divisions of Reynolds, King, and Ricketts* would have stood between Jackson and Longstreet, with Pope advancing from Jackson's other side. Thus, Brawner's Farm could have cost Jackson very dearly, but thanks to the inexplicable actions of a division commander who was probably physically unable to command at the time, it did not. It still stands as a testament to the bravery of the men on both sides however, and the iron discipline and ability of John Gibbon's Black Hats, later to earn the title of Iron Brigade.

Sources:
Alan T. Nolan's The Iron Brigade.
http://www.civilwar.org/battlefields/secondmanassas/second-manassas-history-articles/a-legend-is-born-at-brawners.html


*
Rickett's division had fought at Thoroughfare Gap earlier that day, delaying Longstreet. If King had stood his ground, Ricketts would have been able to join him as well.
 
Last edited:
Mar 2011
1,986
Bulgaria
Pray correct me if I am wrong, but wasn't it Jackson't mission to hold his position until Longstreet arrives? His fault was giving more casualties than his opponents while outnumbering them, indeed, but at the end, he didn't allow his lines to be breached and his army stayed...
 

Viperlord

Ad Honorem
Aug 2010
8,109
VA
His lines to be breached? Did you like, not read the post? He tried to launch a surprise attack on a Federal division that was marching past, blissfully ignorant that Jackson was even there. Jackson was the attacker. He was supposed to wait for Longstreet, but decided to try and use the opportunity to crush King's division. He failed at that, and got nothing but a bloody nose for his trouble. The battle could have cost him dearly if King hadn't for some reason decided to retreat.
 

Underlankers

Ad Honorem
Feb 2013
6,724
This battle and Cedar Mountain are two of the classic examples of how while a brilliant strategist, Ol' Stony was at most a mediocre tactician. What this also shows is that the Iron Brigade was badass to the bone.
 
Aug 2011
209
Where I retired.
His lines to be breached? Did you like, not read the post? He tried to launch a surprise attack on a Federal division that was marching past, blissfully ignorant that Jackson was even there. Jackson was the attacker. He was supposed to wait for Longstreet, but decided to try and use the opportunity to crush King's division. He failed at that, and got nothing but a bloody nose for his trouble. The battle could have cost him dearly if King hadn't for some reason decided to retreat.
Stonewall made the decision to hold King in place because he had the better location for fighting. Of course you would never speak of Longstreet
dawdling along checking out the scenery.
 

Viperlord

Ad Honorem
Aug 2010
8,109
VA
Stonewall made the decision to hold King in place because he had the better location for fighting. Of course you would never speak of Longstreet
dawdling along checking out the scenery.
What does this have to do with anything? I specifically said Jackson attacked because he thought he had an excellent opportunity to wreck King's division. And Longstreet was hardly dawdling; according to Hennessey, Lee was with Longstreet and it was Lee who regulated the pace of the march.
 

Viperlord

Ad Honorem
Aug 2010
8,109
VA
This battle and Cedar Mountain are two of the classic examples of how while a brilliant strategist, Ol' Stony was at most a mediocre tactician. What this also shows is that the Iron Brigade was badass to the bone.
Agreed. In a pitched battle, I'd take Gibbon over Jackson any day.
 

Viperlord

Ad Honorem
Aug 2010
8,109
VA
Correction to the OP; I indicated in the post that the gap that developed in Gibbon's line had two regiments on each side of the gap. As you can see in the map, it was actually the Sixth Wisconsin that was separated from the rest of the brigade.
 

Fiver

Ad Honorem
Jul 2012
3,776
This battle and Cedar Mountain are two of the classic examples of how while a brilliant strategist, Ol' Stony was at most a mediocre tactician. What this also shows is that the Iron Brigade was badass to the bone.
Agreed. When green troops outnumbered nearly 3-to-1 are surprise attacked by veterans from one of the most elite units in the war, you'd expect panic, not giving better than they got.
 

Apachewarlord

Ad Honorem
Jun 2012
5,689
Hippy town U.S.A.!
Pray correct me if I am wrong, but wasn't it Jackson't mission to hold his position until Longstreet arrives? His fault was giving more casualties than his opponents while outnumbering them, indeed, but at the end, he didn't allow his lines to be breached and his army stayed...
Umm, this is the opposite of the argument you use against Grant? I guess it only applies when talking about a union general.