Did India's leadership hope after partition that Pakistan will eventually rejoin India?

Status
Closed
Oct 2015
1,059
India
#61
@Ashoka maurya

below is content analysis of your post # 54:

....

what you like:

pakistan (ruled by its existing dispensation), pakistani scenario (only ethnic issue), taliban (which is better than RSS, treated jews in afghanistan well), ancient hindus (thousands of years back were tolerant), pakistan and afghanistan (tolerant of minorities), hindus in pakistan are not considered inferior ethnic race (not disdained for their poverty, not a burden), islamic mindset (all are equal, including religious minorities)

what you dislike:

india (ruled by modi and yogi), indian scenario (threefold issues: ethnic, caste as well as religious intolerance), RSS (which is worse than taliban, is anti-islamic & islamophobic), today's hindus (intolerant), india (hindutva intolerant of minorities), muslims in india are considered inferior ethnic race in india (low caste converts, poor, backward), hindutva caste mindset (see muslims as people of low birth, low rights, and low people)

conclusion(s):

western and hindutva propaganda is misleading people and society in india is falling because of caste issue.
....

if you are an indian, then there is serious alienation issue. if you are not, then why shelter behind an indian sounding name?
 
Last edited:
Mar 2019
1,463
KL
#62
define india

if you are an indian, then there is serious alienation issue. if you are not, then why shelter behind an indian sounding name?
btw i have reported your post for personal attack, you may like my post or dislike it, but you trying to state by likes or dislikes is going beyond your limits.

regards
 
Jun 2017
524
usa
#64
@Ashoka maurya

below is content analysis of your post # 54:

....

what you like:

pakistan (ruled by its existing dispensation), pakistani scenario (only ethnic issue), taliban (which is better than RSS, treated jews in afghanistan well), ancient hindus (thousands of years back were tolerant), pakistan and afghanistan (tolerant of minorities), hindus in pakistan are not considered inferior ethnic race (not disdained for their poverty, not a burden), islamic mindset (all are equal, including religious minorities)

what you dislike:

india (ruled by modi and yogi), indian scenario (threefold issues: ethnic, caste as well as religious intolerance), RSS (which is worse than taliban, is anti-islamic & islamophobic), today's hindus (intolerant), india (hindutva intolerant of minorities), muslims in india are considered inferior ethnic race in india (low caste converts, poor, backward), hindutva caste mindset (see muslims as people of low birth, low rights, and low people)

conclusion(s):

western and hindutva propaganda is misleading people and society in india is falling because of caste issue.
....

if you are an indian, then there is serious alienation issue. if you are not, then why shelter behind an indian sounding name?

Well summarized.
 
Apr 2019
293
India
#65
@Ashoka maurya

below is content analysis of your post # 54:

....

what you like:

pakistan (ruled by its existing dispensation), pakistani scenario (only ethnic issue), taliban (which is better than RSS, treated jews in afghanistan well), ancient hindus (thousands of years back were tolerant), pakistan and afghanistan (tolerant of minorities), hindus in pakistan are not considered inferior ethnic race (not disdained for their poverty, not a burden), islamic mindset (all are equal, including religious minorities)

what you dislike:

india (ruled by modi and yogi), indian scenario (threefold issues: ethnic, caste as well as religious intolerance), RSS (which is worse than taliban, is anti-islamic & islamophobic), today's hindus (intolerant), india (hindutva intolerant of minorities), muslims in india are considered inferior ethnic race in india (low caste converts, poor, backward), hindutva caste mindset (see muslims as people of low birth, low rights, and low people)

conclusion(s):

western and hindutva propaganda is misleading people and society in india is falling because of caste issue.
....

if you are an indian, then there is serious alienation issue. if you are not, then why shelter behind an indian sounding name?
He is Pakistani and he is probably living in Malaysia, the country which is protecting goat Zakir Naik(Whose Indian followers joined ISIS in Syria and one of them was shot down in Afganistan a few days ago).
Despite having so many terror threats both inside and outside of country global media is trying to sell a phantom called 'Hindutva' terror but they are totally silent on all of global jihadis causing havoc in the country. We are probably living in the Animal Farm. If cracking on terrorists(which previous goverment was hesitant to do and whose leaders showed active support for terrorists in front of media and earned hate of the public !) is fanaticism and fascim then we need to amend the meaning of these words from dictionary.
 

Devdas

Ad Honorem
Apr 2015
4,487
India
#66
Communal division does not exist in Pakistan because Hindus know about their position and place in that country.
No one except a Muslim can become the prime minister of Pakistan.

RSS and Modi have become a bogeyman for the likes of you. Good thing majority of Indians did not fall for this leftist propaganda and voted for the best of the country.
Even a slight fear of secularizing Pakistan constitution led to widespread violence in Pakistan by Mullahs and the Pakistani minister had to resign and they people complain about other countries.
 
Last edited:

Naomasa298

Forum Staff
Apr 2010
33,644
T'Republic of Yorkshire
#67
He is Pakistani and he is probably living in Malaysia, the country which is protecting goat Zakir Naik(Whose Indian followers joined ISIS in Syria and one of them was shot down in Afganistan a few days ago).
Despite having so many terror threats both inside and outside of country global media is trying to sell a phantom called 'Hindutva' terror but they are totally silent on all of global jihadis causing havoc in the country. We are probably living in the Animal Farm. If cracking on terrorists(which previous goverment was hesitant to do and whose leaders showed active support for terrorists in front of media and earned hate of the public !) is fanaticism and fascim then we need to amend the meaning of these words from dictionary.

This post is NOT acceptable on this site. Not only are you attacking and drawing conclusions abour a poster, you are flamebaiting and throwing insults into the bargain.

Do NOT make another post like this, anywhere on this site.
 

Naomasa298

Forum Staff
Apr 2010
33,644
T'Republic of Yorkshire
#68
if you are an indian, then there is serious alienation issue. if you are not, then why shelter behind an indian sounding name?
Wether he is or is not an Indian is irrelevant as far as his participation, motive, or choice of username is concerned. Is that clear?
 

Naomasa298

Forum Staff
Apr 2010
33,644
T'Republic of Yorkshire
#69
To all of you: This may be the standard of debate you are used to on other nationalist forums, but it is NOT acceptable here. There will be NO mud slinging, aspersion casting based on someone's perceived nationality, ethnicity, caste, tribe, religion or anything else, no insults whether direct or implied and no name calling.

IF this continues, we will simply ban all discussion about the subcontinent, and ban all the involved parties.

If you want discussion to continue, you will do so in a respectful and civilised manner, adhering to the rules of Historum. If you can't do that, don't participate.
 
Status
Closed

Similar History Discussions