If Hitler died in WWI, would there have still been a Führer?


Ad Honorem
Apr 2017
Las Vegas, NV USA
He signed up as an enlisted man. why would he become an officer? ONly the German aristocracy become officers, and even in Britain it worked on a similar process. It's only these days that officer ranks are chosen largely on merit and not status.
At the time, Hitler could have been promoted a bit higher. His superiors did not trust him to lead others. He was too willing to take risks which made him well suited for one man operations such as message runner. He won two Iron Crosses which was very unusual for a corporal.

I agree with the general consensus here that if the still obscure corporal were killed in combat, Germany would still have become a dictatorship after the Great Depression began. Before 1933 the KDP and NSDAP were fighting in the streets. It wasn't clear who would win but it could be argued that the military establishment would not have allowed a communist dictatorship. The the political right was apparently weak (without the NSDAP) so I think it would have been a military dictatorship. I love the name Blumentritt but I'm not saying he'd be the leader.:winktongue:
Last edited:

Similar History Discussions