- Apr 2010
- T'Republic of Yorkshire
Adelaide has a Test ground too. All you could want.
I'd be careful about holding Paris up as a model in this regard. The nineteenth century redevelopment (beautiful as it is) hasn't helped with twentieth century population growth. In keeping with many French cities, Paris has an enormous hinterland of pretty depressing housing estates, many of which reminds one of the worst excesses of 60's planning in Britain where huge swathes of people were moved out from city centres into new communities in the sky (Easterhouse near Glasgow being a good example), where no services were provided and people were left isolated and sundered from their city centres.At least multistory construction saves rural land and it need not be dreary. Paris solved this problem in the 1850's when the city was largely rebuilt. The population density is over 20000 per sq km (over 50000 per sq mile) within the city limits, but people love it
I think there has to be a case study about that situation.My point is not that that US cities are great places to live. Some are better than others. My point is that the move to the suburbs preceded the decay of many cities like Detroit. The worse things got in the cities, the more the people fled. Detroit in 1950 was actually a city of well built single family homes. The flight coincided with the building of freeways and accelerated.
I think there has to be a case study about that situation.
1-Maybe the people saw the writing on the wall but could not get out until they saw the freeways as a facilitator.
2-Maybe the people did not like the unchangeable way the city is run but saw the freeways as a facilitator to getting out.
3-Or something was done to the people that forced them to take their families out of that city irrespective of the time and distance cost.
or maybe it was something else that made the the freeways as the facilitator/savior.
Interestingly enough, I moved further from DC about 7 years ago, I have had not my child yet but the place was near a very good school, not to mention my mother was nearby as well, it took the county that much time to destroy the school's ranking and performance through "something I am yet to figure out" , knowing fully well they are not going to tell me why, I am going to try to move to a different district with a better school and hope he graduates before the county achieves similar damage to that school.
I lived in the city until I was schooled aged then moved to the suburbs. In my neighborhood, were Blacks, children/grandchildren of Jewish, Indian and many European ethnicities. There were two Jewish "temples," a Hindu place of worship, and all kind of Christian churches. This was in the 1970s. People moved there because they were fleeing the blight and crime of the city. The school system far exceeded that of the city I left. I see these as advantages for myself. Cities are exciting when you are young. For many though, once you have a family with children to raise and they and your job take priority, the suburbs can serve one well.I grew up in suburban New York. We had the usual amenities of a single family home, private yard, a two car garage, etc. There were no blacks, native Spanish speakers and just a few Asians. That's the way everyone liked it. It was overwhelmingly Republican in contrast to the "city" where the Democratic Party dominated. Although my father worked in Manhattan, we rarely went there. As an uncritical adolescent I had no complaints. As an a young adult I came to hate the suburbs. I never lived in the suburbs as an adult. I preferred small university towns with easy access to the countryside.
Suburbs are wasteful inefficient places. They cut off true urban areas from the countryside by mile after mile of dreary tact housing and ugly commercial development. Humans have long lived in cities or rural areas. It seems natural. I blame suburbs for much of the modern cultural/social dysfunction in the US. Europe has done a better job of keeping their cities viable but the they are not immune from the disease of suburbanization. Does anyone disagree? If you agree, what can done to prevent the planet from the becoming a wasteland of suburban sprawl?
|Similar History Discussions||History Forum||Date|
|English Asylum Life for Victorian Women||European History|
|Born in New Territories, Hong Kong, 1879, how would you spend your life?||Speculative History|
|What would you do with your life if you were born in the same place as in real life, but 100 years earlier?||Speculative History|
|What was the average life span of a roman plebs person?||European History|
|Similar History Discussions|
|English Asylum Life for Victorian Women|
|Born in New Territories, Hong Kong, 1879, how would you spend your life?|
|What would you do with your life if you were born in the same place as in real life, but 100 years earlier?|
|What was the average life span of a roman plebs person?|