The victorious Allies support a Ukrainian state after WWI

Futurist

Ad Honoris
May 2014
15,664
SoCal
#1
If the victorious Allies would have supported the existence of a Ukrainian state after the end of World War I (something which they should have done IMHO given that there was no guarantee that Russia was going to shake off Bolshevik rule), how much higher would the odds be of an independent Ukrainian state surviving after the end of World War I would have been?

As you hopefully know, Poland and the Baltic countries were able to retain their independence after the end of WWI while Ukraine unfortunately couldn't (and neither could the Caucasian republics--though Ukraine is far more important than they are due to Ukraine's much larger population). In turn, this makes me wonder if there was some way to change this and to prevent Ukraine from falling to the Bolsheviks in 1919-1921.

Ukrainians are one of the few peoples whose fate would have been better off had the Central Powers won WWI and thus I am wondering if there was any way for the Allies to win WWI and yet for Ukraine to retain its independence (even under a new government) and avoid Communism (at least until the 1930s or 1940s).

Anyway, any thoughts on this?

Also, FTR, it appears that Ukraine indeed had its own delegation to the 1919 Paris Peace Conference--where they presented this proposal for an independent Ukraine's borders:



These were ultimately the borders that Ukraine got in 1991 with the exception of Rostov and the Kuban (both of which remained under Russian rule)--borders which Ukraine kept until 2014 when it lost Crimea and also de facto lost a large part of the Donbass.
 

Futurist

Ad Honoris
May 2014
15,664
SoCal
#2
This topic reminds me of a previous comment by Michael Mills either on this forum or on another forum where he said that it's ironic that the Western Powers supported Russia's claim to Ukraine at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference only to condemn Russian aggression against Ukraine almost a century later.

My, oh my, how times have changed! Had they had the benefit of hindsight, I wonder if the politicians and decision-makers at the 1919 Paris Peace Conference would have made a different decision in regards to Ukraine (even if they wouldn't have ultimately been able to get their decision to stick).
 
Likes: Edratman

Similar History Discussions