Was one WWII opponent "Germany" or "Nazi Germany"...

Oct 2019
6
NC, USA
I'm new here. For certain much has been said about my topic. How, at Historum, would I access what has already been written?
 

Futurist

Ad Honoris
May 2014
21,827
SoCal
Nazi Germany and Germany are one country. Nazi Germany is simply referring to what Germany was in 1933-1945 when it was under Nazi rule. Hence the adjective Nazi to describe the noun Germany.
 

Zip

Jan 2018
487
Comancheria
I figure calling our enemy in WW II the Nazis or Nazi Germans rather than just plain Germans is letting the Germans off the hook. It's like saying that in 1846 the Democrats made war on Mexico.

I have to start the AJP Taylor books on Germany I bought last year; they've just been laying about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist

Chlodio

Forum Staff
Aug 2016
4,471
Dispargum
^That could very well be the case. Nazi Germany is an aberation. Germany is the norm. It may have been to let post-war Germans off the hook, or it may have been to distinguish Hitler's Germany from German-Americans who had nothing to do with Naziism. It could have also been a way of saying we are at war with the Nazi government but not the German people.

I've been comparing Nazi Germany to Communist Russia or Communist China. Communist Russia distinguishes the Soviet Union from Czarist Russia, but why not just say Soviet Russia or the Soviet Union? Communist China does make more sense because there is or was a non-Communist China in Taiwan. No one ever described East Germany as Communist Germany.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Zip and Futurist
Apr 2014
227
Liverpool, England
It is a while since I have looked at one, but there used to be British comics including stories set during the Second World War in which the enemy was invariably referred to as the Nazis - never the Germans. I presume this was to make a distinction between the enemy of 1939-45 and our gallant German allies in NATO.

No-one seems to have answered the original question. To find out what has been said about a topic before, you can use the search box at top right.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist