Who won the battle of the Hydaspes, Alexander or Porus??

Mar 2018
655
UK
#32
It would be cool if you guys can find it in yourselves to also respect & revere the ancient ancestor and/or predecessor nations of other modern day nations, such as Iraq & Syria for instance, the same way & to the same degree that you all quite obviously respect & revere the ancestor and/or predecessor nations of modern day Greece.
???
No one here has shown a lack of respect to anyone, apart from you to the Greeks. You said that because they lose to the Turks in 1500AD, they must have lost to the Indians in 500BC, and said so in clearly offensive terms. Frankly, such a line of reasoning is pretty much racist too.

If you think that claiming that Alexander won Hydaspes is a lack of respect to ancient Indian cultures, then the problem is entirely with your fragile mental state and your inability to accept that those you think of as your ancestors were anything but invincible.
 

rvsakhadeo

Ad Honorem
Sep 2012
8,924
India
#33
Looking to the discussion so far, it is rather evident that in the particular battle of the Hydaspes Porus was defeated. Indian pride is not hurt. Porus was ruling over a small kingdom and he fought his best. IIRC, Alexander then went south along the western bank of the Sindhu (aka Indus) river, where he fought yet another battle with a small sized force commanded either by a king or by a Republic under whom the army was serving. In that battle, he received an arrow wound in his elbow. This was probably the only battle wound he ever received. His army not being interested in going into Mainland India, more so because of the reports of the army of King Nanda, a much larger force advancing from Pataliputra (aka present day Patna, Bihar ), Alexander departed from India. Not a very distinguished campaign.
 

Dan Howard

Ad Honorem
Aug 2014
4,198
Australia
#34
In that battle, he received an arrow wound in his elbow. This was probably the only battle wound he ever received.
Are you talking about Porus or Alexander? There is at least one Greek source that said Porus was wounded at Hydapses. Alexander was wounded by virtually every weapon known to man at that time, the worst injury was the arrow that pierced his lung while fighting the Mallians.
 
Last edited:

Similar History Discussions