Why France did not insist occupying natural borders of Frannce and try to annex Rhineland in 1945 ?

Apr 2014
404
Istanbul Turkey
Considering France was attacked and invaded not once or twice but three times from German launcing pads in west bank of Rhine in 75 years (1871-1945) with devastating consequences , why France did not occupy and annex Rhinelands permenantly (like Ferdinand Foch wished in 1918) at the end of war in 1945 ? Russians occupied East Prussia , Polish territory was shifted to Oder towards westwards , Silesia was taken over by Czechs and Polish goverment. Why France in post war truma did not gain any buffer zone territory for security ?
 
Last edited:
Apr 2014
404
Istanbul Turkey
Germany did not seem like a threat either after Paris Peace Conferance in 1919 , 20 years later they curb stomped France. East Prussia was full of Germans too.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist
Apr 2017
732
Lemuria
Considering France was attacked and invaded not once or twice but three times from German launcing pads in west bank of Rhine in 75 years (1871-1945) with devastating consequences , why France did not occupy and annex Rhinelands permenantly (like Ferdinand Foch wished in 1918) at the end of war in 1945 ? Russians occupied East Prussia , Polish territory was shifted to Oder towards westwards , Silesia was taken over by Czechs and Polish goverment. Why France in post war truma did not gain any buffer zone territory for security ?
Well, the Germans were completely defeated and the French in a weakened state. I'm sure they originally had a predatory plan for Germany but once they realized the Soviet threat was imminent, a strong Western Germany was in the interest of the French as a buffer. The French were also creating nuclear weapons. They were probably planning on using them in Western Germany as a last recourse if conventional warfare failed. In the end a strong Germany and reconciliation between France and Germany proved key to both countries economic success as well as Europe in general. Cooperation is better than competition most of the time. The EU or the US (depending on the strength of the Euro or dollar) has the highest GDP on Earth.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist
Oct 2018
22
Australia
France invaded Germany after Germany invaded Poland in 1939. France crossed the Maginot Line in 1939 into the Saar during the Phoney War. After the war, France occupied Saarland until 1957.
 

Chlodio

Forum Staff
Aug 2016
4,575
Dispargum
The prevailing philosophy of 1945 was to avoid a future war. Everyone understood by then that the Treaty of Versailles had been a major cause of WW2. No one was interested in another 1919-style solution. Wasn't the French occupation of the Saarland similar to the US, British, and Soviet occupations of Germany that continued throughout the Cold War? Still an effective way of controlling Germany but also a different solution than Versailles - and far more successful.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist

betgo

Ad Honorem
Jul 2011
6,423
. Wasn't the French occupation of the Saarland similar to the US, British, and Soviet occupations of Germany that continued throughout the Cold War?
I believe the US and Britain officially ended the occupation much earlier than 1959. However, they kept troops there into the 1980s ostensibly to defend against the Soviet threat. East Germany became a Communist state that also had Soviet troops.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist
Mar 2018
837
UK
Even if the French wanted to, I doubt the UK, USA or even Russia would have allowed it. France was hardly in a strong negotiating power in 1945.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist

Pendennis

Ad Honorem
Mar 2013
3,386
Kirkcaldy, Scotland
rFrance was alloted the French zone of occupation in 1945 along with the American Russian and British zones of occupation.. which eventually merged to form Western Germany while the Soviets founded the DDR in East Germany and Berlin.
In 1955 the Soviets agreed to give up tteir claims to occupied Austria so the a new state of Austria was born in that year.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Futurist

Willempie

Ad Honorem
Jul 2015
5,487
Netherlands
Even if the French wanted to, I doubt the UK, USA or even Russia would have allowed it. France was hardly in a strong negotiating power in 1945.
As was proven when France had to swallow her pride when West-Germany was formed and became a NATO member